Your roof is one of the most critical components of your home, protecting you and your family from the elements. Whether it’s shielding against heavy rain, harsh winds, or extreme temperatures, a well-maintained roof ensures your home stays safe and secure. However, when your roof requires repairs or a full replacement, choosing the right contractor is just as important as the work itself.
Unfortunately, the roofing industry is a prime target for scammers and dishonest contractors who take advantage of homeowners, especially after storms or natural disasters. These fraudsters may offer “too good to be true” deals, pressure you into signing contracts, or disappear after taking your money—leaving you with subpar work or an unfinished job.
Knowing how to spot a roofing scam can save you thousands of dollars and prevent future headaches. By understanding the warning signs and learning how to verify a contractor’s credibility, you can protect your home and investment. In this guide, we’ll walk you through the most common roofing scams, how to avoid them, and the steps you should take to find a reliable, experienced roofing professional.
Common Roofing Scams and How to Spot Them
1. Storm Chasers Offering “Too Good to Be True” Deals
After a major storm, homeowners are often in a vulnerable position, looking for quick repairs to fix roof damage. This is when storm chasers—fraudulent contractors who follow storms to scam homeowners—appear. They often go door-to-door, claiming they can offer immediate repairs at a deeply discounted rate. They may even claim they have leftover materials from a nearby job, making it seem like a rare opportunity you shouldn’t pass up.
🔴 Red Flags:
✔ High-pressure sales tactics—They insist you sign a contract on the spot before you have time to research them.
✔ Lack of local presence—They have no permanent business address, local references, or company history in your area.
✔ Full payment upfront—They demand large sums before work begins, then either do poor-quality work or disappear entirely.
✔ No license or insurance—Storm chasers often operate without proper licensing, leaving you liable for damages or injuries during the project.
✅ How to Avoid:
✔ Verify credentials—Check if they have a valid business license, insurance, and a local office. Avoid companies that only provide a P.O. Box.
✔ Check reviews and references—Search online reviews, ask for references, and contact previous clients to confirm their work quality.
✔ Get a written contract and estimate—Legitimate contractors provide a detailed estimate outlining materials, labor, and costs before work starts.
✔ Don’t rush into a decision—Take your time to compare contractors, even if your roof needs urgent repairs. A little research can prevent a costly mistake.
By staying cautious and avoiding high-pressure sales tactics, you can protect yourself from falling victim to storm-chasing roofing scams.
2. Upfront Payment Scams
One of the most common roofing scams involves contractors asking for full payment before starting any work. While it’s normal for reputable roofers to require a deposit, fraudulent contractors will collect a large sum—or the entire payment—before disappearing without completing the job. Some may start the project but leave it unfinished or perform subpar work, knowing you have little recourse once they’ve been paid.
🔴 Red Flags:
✔ Requests for full payment upfront—They insist on receiving the entire cost before any materials are delivered or work begins.
✔ No written contract—Scammers may avoid putting terms in writing, making it harder for you to hold them accountable.
✔ High-pressure tactics—They push you to pay immediately, sometimes offering a special deal or discount to entice you.
✔ Refusal to accept secure payment methods—They insist on cash payments to avoid leaving a paper trail, making it difficult to track them down later.
✅ How to Avoid:
✔ Stick to a structured payment schedule—Legitimate contractors typically require a reasonable deposit (often 10–30%) upfront, with the remaining payments tied to project milestones.
✔ Never pay in full before work is completed—Only release the final payment after you have thoroughly inspected the completed job.
✔ Use a credit card or check—Avoid cash payments, as credit cards and checks provide payment protection and documentation in case of fraud.
✔ Get everything in writing—Ensure your contract clearly states the payment schedule, work timeline, and scope of work before signing.
By being cautious with upfront payments and only paying for work as it is completed, you can protect yourself from losing money to roofing scams.
3. Inflated Damage Claims
Some dishonest roofing contractors take advantage of homeowners by exaggerating damage or claiming that a full roof replacement is necessary when only minor repairs are needed. They often approach homeowners after storms, offering free inspections to lure them in. Once they get onto the roof, they might claim to have found severe issues—even if none exist—just to push you into a costly repair or unnecessary replacement.
🔴 Red Flags:
✔ A sudden “discovery” of major issues—A contractor offers a free inspection, then conveniently finds extensive damage that wasn’t noticeable before.
✔ High-pressure tactics—They insist that you need to act immediately and may even try to rush you into filing an insurance claim.
✔ Lack of visual evidence—They don’t provide clear photos or detailed explanations of the supposed damage.
✔ Push to work exclusively with your insurance claim—They may insist on handling the entire process themselves, often inflating the claim amount.
✅ How to Avoid:
✔ Get a second opinion—Always consult another licensed and reputable roofer before making a decision, especially if significant work is being recommended.
✔ Request before and after photos—A legitimate contractor should provide clear, high-resolution images of the damage, along with explanations of the needed repairs.
✔ Consult your insurance company first—Before filing a claim, contact your insurance provider directly to discuss the situation and determine the best course of action.
✔ Be wary of contractors pushing insurance fraud—Some scammers encourage homeowners to inflate their claims or fake damages, which can lead to legal consequences for you.
By taking these precautions, you can avoid falling victim to inflated damage claims and ensure that your roof receives only the necessary repairs or replacements it truly needs.
4. Unlicensed or Uninsured Contractors
Some roofing contractors operate illegally without proper licensing or insurance, putting homeowners at risk of financial and legal trouble. If an unlicensed roofer performs subpar work, you may have little recourse if something goes wrong. Worse, if they lack liability insurance or workers’ compensation, you could be held responsible for injuries or damages that occur during the project.
🔴 Red Flags:
✔ No proof of licensing—The contractor hesitates or outright refuses to show their business license or credentials.
✔ No insurance coverage—They claim it’s unnecessary or expect you to cover potential accidents.
✔ Extremely low bids—Their price is significantly cheaper than other estimates, often because they cut corners or use unqualified workers.
✔ No written contract—They avoid paperwork, making it difficult to hold them accountable if issues arise.
✅ How to Avoid:
✔ Ask for their license number—Reputable contractors will provide their state license number, which you can verify online through local government websites.
✔ Confirm insurance coverage—Ensure they carry both general liability insurance (to protect your property) and workers’ compensation insurance (to cover any injuries on the job).
✔ Request written documentation—A legitimate contractor will have a detailed contract outlining the scope of work, materials, costs, and timeline before any work begins.
✔ Be cautious of cash-only payments—Scammers often insist on cash payments to avoid a paper trail. Stick to check or credit card transactions for added security.
Hiring an unlicensed or uninsured roofer may seem like a cost-saving decision at first, but the risks far outweigh the savings. Always verify a contractor’s credentials before signing any agreements.
5. Low-Bid, High-Cost Scams
Some roofing contractors use a bait-and-switch pricing tactic by offering a suspiciously low bid to secure your business, only to inflate costs mid-project with unexpected charges. Once work has started, they may claim they “discovered” additional issues that require immediate attention and extra fees, leaving homeowners feeling pressured to pay more than originally agreed upon.
🔴 Red Flags:
✔ The quote is drastically lower than competitors—While competitive pricing is expected, a bid that seems too good to be true usually is.
✔ No cost breakdown provided—Scammers avoid listing materials, labor, and permit costs to leave room for hidden fees later.
✔ Sudden price increases after work starts—They claim additional repairs are “mandatory” but won’t provide proof of the damage.
✔ Rushed contract signing—They pressure you to sign quickly before you have time to review or compare quotes.
✅ How to Avoid:
✔ Get multiple estimates—Obtain at least three quotes from reputable roofing companies to compare costs and detect any major discrepancies.
✔ Demand a detailed contract—Ensure all materials, labor, and fees are clearly outlined, including any potential additional costs before signing.
✔ Ask about unforeseen expenses upfront—A reliable roofer will discuss possible complications before starting the job, not after.
✔ Avoid vague pricing terms—Beware of contracts that list “TBD” (to be determined) or “cost-plus pricing” without specific figures.
A legitimate roofing contractor provides transparent pricing and will communicate openly about costs. Avoid contractors who use low-bid tactics to lure you in, only to surprise you with excessive charges once work is underway.
How to Find a Trustworthy Roofing Contractor
Avoiding scams is only part of the process—you also need to know how to find a professional roofer who delivers quality work and fair pricing. Follow these steps to choose a reputable roofing contractor.
- Verify Licensing and Insurance
Before hiring a roofing contractor, it’s essential to confirm that they are properly licensed and insured. A legitimate roofing company will have state and local licensing that proves they meet industry standards and legal requirements.
✔ Ask for their state license number and verify it through official government websites or local building authorities. Many states provide online databases where you can check a contractor’s licensing status.
✔ Ensure they carry general liability and workers’ compensation insurance. Liability insurance protects your home from damages caused during the roofing project, while workers’ compensation protects you from being held financially responsible if a worker is injured on your property.
✔ Request proof of insurance and make sure it specifically covers roofing work. Some companies may have general business insurance, but not coverage for roofing, which is considered high-risk work. Always ask for a copy of their insurance policy and verify its validity with the insurance provider.
A licensed and insured contractor demonstrates professionalism, compliance with safety regulations, and accountability—giving you peace of mind that your roofing project is in safe hands.
2. Check Reviews and References
Before hiring a roofing contractor, take the time to research their reputation online and through direct customer feedback. A trustworthy roofer will have a track record of satisfied clients and positive reviews across multiple platforms.
✔ Look up the company on trusted review sites such as Google, Yelp, the Better Business Bureau (BBB), and Angi (formerly Angie’s List). These platforms provide real customer feedback, ratings, and any complaints filed against the company. A high rating with consistent positive reviews is a good sign—but be cautious of companies with only a handful of reviews, as they may be new or trying to hide past issues.
✔ Ask for at least three references from past customers. A professional roofing contractor should have no problem providing contact information for satisfied clients who can vouch for their work. If a company hesitates or refuses to provide references, that’s a major red flag.
✔ Contact references and ask about their experience. Questions to ask include:
- Was the contractor professional and reliable?
- Did the project stay on budget, or were there unexpected costs?
- Was the work completed on time?
- Were there any issues after installation, and how were they handled?
Speaking directly with past clients gives you insight into the contractor’s reliability, work quality, and customer service, helping you make an informed hiring decision.
3. Get a Written Estimate and Contract
Before committing to a roofing contractor, always request a detailed, written estimate that outlines all aspects of the project. A professional roofer will provide a transparent and itemized quote, ensuring there are no surprises along the way.
✔ The estimate should include a full breakdown of costs, covering:
- Materials: Type, brand, and quantity of roofing materials to be used.
- Labor: The cost of installation, repairs, or replacement work.
- Additional services: Such as debris removal, inspections, or warranties.
- Permits and fees: If applicable, ensure these are included in the total estimate.
✔ A structured payment schedule should be outlined in the contract. This prevents the risk of paying too much upfront and ensures payments align with completed work. A standard agreement often requires:
- A small deposit before work begins.
- Incremental payments as project milestones are reached.
- The final payment upon completion and inspection of the work.
✔ The contract should also specify the estimated timeline for completion. This helps manage expectations and holds the contractor accountable for meeting deadlines. Be wary of vague timelines or promises that seem too fast or too slow, as rushed work can lead to poor quality, and excessive delays may signal a lack of professionalism.
✔ Avoid vague contracts or handshake agreements—always get everything in writing. Verbal promises can be easily forgotten or disputed, while a signed contract protects both you and the contractor, ensuring clarity and accountability throughout the roofing project.
4. Ask About Workmanship Warranties
A trustworthy roofing contractor will stand behind their work by offering warranties on both materials and labor. This ensures that you’re protected in case of installation defects, unexpected leaks, or material failures.
✔ Understand the difference between material and workmanship warranties:
- Material Warranty: Covers defects in the roofing materials, usually provided by the manufacturer. These warranties can last anywhere from 10 to 50 years, depending on the brand and type of roofing material.
- Workmanship Warranty: Covers the installation and labor performed by the contractor. A reputable roofer typically offers a 5 to 10-year workmanship warranty, ensuring they will fix any installation-related issues at no extra cost.
✔ Ask what happens if something goes wrong after installation. Important questions to consider:
- Who is responsible for repairs if a problem arises within the warranty period?
- Does the warranty cover leaks, improper sealing, or ventilation issues?
- Are there any exclusions, such as damage caused by storms or lack of maintenance?
✔ Make sure the warranty terms are clearly included in the contract. If a contractor refuses to provide written warranty details or offers only verbal assurances, consider it a red flag. A legitimate roofer will always outline warranty coverage, duration, and conditions in writing to give you peace of mind.
By securing a comprehensive workmanship warranty, you ensure that your investment is protected and that the contractor is held accountable for delivering high-quality work.
5. Look for Industry Certifications
A reputable roofing contractor doesn’t just claim to be experienced—they back it up with industry certifications from leading manufacturers. These certifications indicate that the roofer has undergone specialized training, meets strict quality standards, and is committed to professional excellence.
✔ Why Certifications Matter
- Certified contractors are required to stay up to date with the latest roofing techniques, safety standards, and product innovations.
- Manufacturers only certify contractors who demonstrate consistent quality workmanship and maintain high customer satisfaction ratings.
- Hiring a certified roofer can give you access to extended warranties, exclusive materials, and better workmanship guarantees.
✔ Top Industry Certifications to Look For
- GAF Master Elite® Certification – This designation is given to only 2% of roofing contractors in North America and requires rigorous training, proper licensing, and a strong reputation for customer service.
- Owens Corning Preferred Contractor – Owens Corning certifies contractors who meet high insurance and professionalism standards while demonstrating expertise in installing their roofing products.
- CertainTeed SELECT ShingleMaster™ – This certification ensures the contractor has completed advanced technical training and is qualified to install CertainTeed products with enhanced warranty options.
- HAAG Certified Inspector – This certification is particularly important for storm damage assessments, ensuring the contractor can properly identify hail, wind, and structural damage.
✔ How to Verify a Roofer’s Certification
- Ask the contractor to show proof of certification badges or documents.
- Visit the manufacturer’s official website and use their contractor locator tool to verify certification status.
- Be wary of contractors falsely claiming certification without proof—some scammers try to mislead homeowners with fake credentials.
By choosing a certified roofing contractor, you ensure that your project is in skilled and trustworthy hands. Certifications provide an added layer of assurance that your roof will be installed or repaired with expert craftsmanship and top-quality materials.
6. Avoid High-Pressure Sales Tactics
A trustworthy roofing contractor understands that replacing or repairing a roof is a significant investment and should never pressure you into making an immediate decision. Unfortunately, some fraudulent roofers use aggressive sales tactics to manipulate homeowners into signing contracts before they have time to research or compare options.
✔ Common High-Pressure Tactics to Watch Out For
- “Limited-Time Offer!” – Scammers may claim their deal is only available today, pressuring you to commit before you can compare other bids.
- “Your Roof is Unsafe!” – Some dishonest contractors exaggerate damage to make you panic and rush into a costly repair or replacement.
- “We Have Leftover Materials!” – Fraudulent roofers may claim they can offer a discount because they have leftover materials from a previous job. This often means poor-quality materials or rushed installations.
- Asking for a Large Deposit Immediately – If a roofer demands a large upfront payment or insists on cash-only transactions, it could be a red flag for a scam.
✔ How to Protect Yourself
- Take Your Time – A reliable contractor won’t mind if you get multiple estimates before making a decision. They will encourage you to compare pricing, reviews, and warranties.
- Do Your Research – Verify the company’s credentials, read customer reviews, and check their Better Business Bureau (BBB) rating before signing anything.
- Get Everything in Writing – Ensure all pricing, work details, and warranty terms are clearly outlined in a contract before making any payments.
- Say No to Door-to-Door Sales – Be cautious of roofers who show up unannounced after a storm, claiming to offer a free inspection. Always research and hire a roofer on your own terms.
By staying alert and avoiding pressure tactics, you can confidently choose a reputable roofing contractor who will deliver quality workmanship without deceptive sales tricks.
Red Flags to Watch for When Hiring a Roofer
🚩 No physical business address or online presence.
🚩 Only accepts cash payments or refuses to provide receipts.
🚩 Offers to work without permits to “save money.”
🚩 Reluctant to answer questions about licensing, warranties, or insurance.
🚩 Uses scare tactics to pressure you into quick decisions.
Final Thoughts: Protect Your Home from Roofing Scams
Choosing a roofing contractor is a big decision—taking shortcuts or hiring the wrong company can result in expensive and dangerous consequences. By staying vigilant and following these guidelines, you can protect yourself from scams and ensure your roof is in the hands of a skilled, trustworthy professional.
✔ Always verify licenses and insurance before hiring a roofer.
✔ Get multiple estimates and compare them carefully.
✔ Read reviews and ask for references to check reputation and past work.
✔ Never pay the full amount upfront—stick to a structured payment schedule.
✔ Insist on a detailed contract that covers all project terms.
By doing your due diligence, you can avoid scams and work with a qualified roofer who delivers quality craftsmanship and peace of mind.
📌 Need a roofing contractor you can trust? Start with verified, licensed professionals in your area!
